cavemem

Bash input={"command":"git push origin documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback 2>&1 | tail -5; git status -sb | head -1"} output={"stdout":"remote: Create pull request for documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback: \nremote: https://bitbucket.org/finaccelteam/osprey/pull-requests/new?source=docs/pr-agent-eval-feedback&t=1 \nremote: \nTo https://bitbucket.org/finaccelteam/osprey.git\n e0cf23c..b73a3fd documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback -> documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback\n## documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback...origin/docs/pr-agent-eval-feedback","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"gitOperation":{"p…

Bash input={"command":"git status --short; git fetch -q origin && git status -sb | head -1 && git log --oneline origin/docs/pr-agent-eval-feedback..HEAD"} output={"stdout":"## documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback...origin/docs/pr-agent-eval-feedback [ahead 1]\nb73a3fd Cut PR review noise and add per-repo BLUF comments (eval Tahap + B)","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Ok commit dan push

Bash input={"command":"sed -i 's/`tests\\/test_review_noise_controls.py` (49)/`tests\\/test_review_noise_controls.py` (51)/' documentation/improver/eval-noise-bluf-implementation-log.md && git add CLAUDE.md application/config.py application/integrations/claude_code_client.py application/integrations/codex_client.py application/integrations/prompts/review_instruction.txt application/integrations/prompts/bluf_instruction.txt application/integrations/prompts/bluf_synthesis_instruction.txt application/integrations/review_engine.py application/integrations/review_prompt.py application/model… output={"stdout":"b73a3fd Cut PR review noise and add per-repo BLUF comments (eval Tahap + B)","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/docs/improver/eval-noise-bluf-implementation-log.md","hunks":[{"oldStart":41,"oldLines":7,"newStart":41,"newLines":7,"lines":[" "," ## Tests"," ","-- New: `tests/test_review_noise_controls.py` (49), `tests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py` (5),","+- New…

Bash input={"command":"uv run pytest -p no:cacheprovider tests/test_review_noise_controls.py tests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py -rA 2>&1 | grep -cE \"^PASSED\"; uv run pytest -p no:cacheprovider tests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py -rA 2>&1 | grep -cE \"^PASSED\""} output={"stdout":"56\n5","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"uv run pytest --collect-only -q -p no:cacheprovider tests/test_review_noise_controls.py tests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py 2>&1 | grep -cE \"::\""} output={"stdout":"0","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"returnCodeInterpretation":"No matches found","noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"uv run pytest --collect-only -q -p no:cacheprovider tests/test_review_noise_controls.py tests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py 2>/dev/null | tail -1; uv run black --check -q tests/test_review_noise_controls.py; echo black=$?; git fetch -q origin && git status -sb | head -1"} output={"stdout":"black=0\n## documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback...origin/docs/pr-agent-eval-feedback","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Write input={"file_path":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/docs/improver/eval-noise-bluf-implementation-log.md","content":"# Implementation log — PR agent eval Tahap + B\n\n- Branch: `docs/pr-agent-eval-feedback` (existing, user choice)\n- Knowledge graph: used — COMPARE vs 2026-09-06 baseline; no review-pipeline drift\n- Commit preference: commit locally\n- CLAUDE.md improver auto-invoke marker: already present\n- Triage: COMPLEX — plan approved after two clarifying rounds\n\n## Steps\n\n| # | Step | Fi… output={"type":"create","filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/docs/improver/eval-noise-bluf-implementation-log.md","content":"# Implementation log — PR agent eval Tahap + B\n\n- Branch: `docs/pr-agent-eval-feedback` (existing, user choice)\n- Knowledge graph: used — COMPARE vs 2026-09-06 baseline; no review-pipeline drift\n- Commit preference: commit locally\n- CLAUDE.md improver auto-invoke marker: already present\n- Triage: COMPLEX — plan approved after two clarifying rounds\n\n## Steps\n\n…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='tests/test_review_noise_controls.py'\ns=open(p).read()\nold='''def test_export_links_bitbucket_replies_to_their_finding(db_session, fake_blobs):\n from scripts.export_eval_data import build_record\n'''\nassert s.count(old)==1\ns=s.replace(old,'''def test_export_links_bitbucket_replies_to_their_finding(db_session, fake_blobs, monkeypatch):\n # script loads repository's.environment into os.environ at import time; that would leak real\n # DATABASE_* values into… output={"stdout":"exit=0","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"returnCodeInterpretation":"No matches found","noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/tests/test_review_noise_controls.py","hunks":[{"oldStart":578,"oldLines":7,"newStart":578,"newLines":12,"lines":[" # ------------------------------------------------------------------ eval export"," "," ","-def test_export_links_bitbucket_replies_to_their_finding(db_session, fake_blobs):",…

Bash input={"command":"uv run pytest -q --tb=short -p no:cacheprovider tests/test_settings_config_backed.py::test_database_url_default_reproduces_the_old_hardcoded_default 2>&1 | grep -E \"^E |passed|failed\" | head; grep -n \"def test_database_url_default_reproduces_the_old_hardcoded_default\" -A20 tests/test_settings_config_backed.py | head -25"} output={"stdout":"263:def test_database_url_default_reproduces_the_old_hardcoded_default():\n264- \"\"\"Settings() with no DATABASE_* environment variables set must build byte-identically to old\n265- plain `database_url: str = \"postgresql+psycopg://app:app@localhost:5432/app\"` field.\"\"\"\n266- settings = Settings(_env_file=None)\n267-\n268- assert settings.database_url == \"postgresql+psycopg://app:application@localhost:5432/app\"\n269-\n270-\n271-def test_database_url_is_built_from_the_split_fields():…

Bash input={"command":"cd /home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey && L=/tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf; grep -E '^(FAILED|ERROR)' $L/pytest-baseline.log | sed 's/ -.*//' | sort > $L/base.txt; grep -E '^(FAILED|ERROR)' $L/pytest-after.log | sed 's/ -.*//' | sort > $L/after.txt; wc -l < $L/base.txt; wc -l < $L/after.txt; echo \"--- new failures:\"; comm -13 $L/base.txt $L/after.txt; echo \"--- fixed:\"; comm -23 $L/base.txt $L/after.txt; grep -c \"^\\.\" $L/pytest-after.log >/dev/null; grep -oE \"[0-9]+ passed\" $… output={"stdout":"193\n194\n--- new failures:\nFAILED tests/test_settings_config_backed.py::test_database_url_default_reproduces_the_old_hardcoded_default\n--- fixed:\n M frontend/src/components/FindingCard.tsx\n M frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.test.tsx\n M frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.tsx\n M frontend/src/components/TriageBar.test.tsx\n M frontend/src/lib/types.ts\n M frontend/src/lib/useTriage.test.ts\n?? frontend/src/components/FindingCard.test.tsx","stderr":"","interr…

<task-notification>
<task-id>b0f7aymy8</task-id>
<tool-use-id>toolu_012xVuo8N8DVbDCzBfi9R5Ec</tool-use-id>
<output-file>/tmp/claude-0/-home-etc-claude-code-work-osprey/52012d37-364a-455d-a224-f13925c4fd41/tasks/b0f7aymy8.output</output-file>
<status>completed</status>
<summary>Background command "uv run pytest -q --tb=no -p no:cacheprovider &gt; /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-after.log 2&gt;&amp;1; echo "exit=$?" &gt;&gt; /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-after.log" completed (exit code 0)</summary>
</task-notification>

Bash input={"command":"sed -i '22s/ confidence: null,/ confidence: null,\\n evidence: null,/' src/lib/useTriage.test.ts && { npx tsc -b; echo \"tsc=$?\"; npx vitest run src/lib/useTriage.test.ts; echo \"vitest=$?\"; npm run build; echo \"build=$?\"; } > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/frontend-2.log 2>&1; grep -E \"tsc=|vitest=|build=|error TS|Tests \" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/frontend-2.log","timeout":600000} output={"stdout":"tsc=0\n Tests 6 passed (6)\nvitest=0\nbuild=0","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/frontend/src/lib/useTriage.test.ts","hunks":[{"oldStart":20,"oldLines":6,"newStart":20,"newLines":7,"lines":[" file_path: \"application/services/example.py\","," line_number: null,"," confidence: null,","+ evidence: null,"," title: \"Example finding\","," reason: \"Because of…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 1,35p src/lib/useTriage.test.ts; grep -rn \"confidence: null\\|confidence: 0\" src --include=*.ts* | grep -v \"TriageBar.test\\|FindingCard.test\""} output={"stdout":"import { describe, it, expect } from \"vitest\";\nimport { renderHook, act } from \"@testing-library/react\";\nimport { useTriage } from \"./useTriage\";\nimport type { Finding } from \"./types\";\n\n/**\n * Regression guard for documentation/improver/review-findings-filter-ui-improvement-plan.md: \n * TriageBar restyle added `filtersActive` derived boolean (for Clear control's visual\n * state) to useTriage's return value. This is purely additive — existing filtering\n * algorith…

Bash input={"command":"cd /home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/frontend && ls node_modules >/dev/null 2>&1 || npm ci > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/npm-ci.log 2>&1; { npx tsc -b; echo \"tsc=$?\"; npx vitest run; echo \"vitest=$?\"; } > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/frontend.log 2>&1; grep -E \"tsc=|vitest=|error TS|Test Files|Tests |FAIL\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/frontend.log | head -30","timeout":600000} output={"stdout":"src/lib/useTriage.test.ts(15,3): error TS2322: Type '{ id: number; severity: Severity; category: string | null; blocking: boolean; file_path: string; line_number: number | null; confidence: number | null; evidence?: \"in_diff\" |... 3 more... | undefined;... 6 more...; impacted_callers: DependencyImpactCaller[] | null; }' is not assignable to type 'Finding'.\ntsc=1\n Test Files 18 passed (18)\n Tests 71 passed (71)\nvitest=0","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,…

Bash input={"command":"uv run pytest -q --tb=no -p no:cacheprovider > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-after.log 2>&1; echo \"exit=$?\" >> /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-after.log","run_in_background":true} output={"stdout":"","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"backgroundTaskId":"b0f7aymy8"}

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\ndef edit(p, pairs):\n s=open(p).read()\n for old,new in pairs:\n assert s.count(old)==1, (p, old[:70], s.count(old))\n s=s.replace(old,new)\n open(p,'w').write(s)\nedit('application/services/review_service.py', [\n(''' \"review %s completed: diff identical to review %s, %s finding(s) carried, nothing posted\",''',''' \"review %s completed: diff identical to review %s, %s finding(s) carried, \"\n \"nothing posted\",'''… output={"stdout":"scripts/export_eval_data.py:52:1: E402 Module level import not at top of file\nscripts/export_eval_data.py:287:101: E501 Line too long (103 > 100)\ntests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py:4:101: E501 Line too long (172 > 100)\nFound 3 errors.\n tests/test_review_prompt_composition.py | 1 +\n tests/test_review_service.py | 8 +-\n 33 files changed, 860 insertions(+), 72 deletions(-)","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 1189p application/services/review_service.py; sed -n 1,4p scripts/export_eval_data.py; sed -n 287p scripts/export_eval_data.py; git show HEAD:scripts/export_eval_data.py | sed -n 1,3p"} output={"stdout":" \"review %s completed: diff identical to review %s, %s finding(s) carried, nothing posted\",\n\"\"\"Export review context for evaluation/audit: one JSON record per review_event over last N\ndays, joining findings, feedback, chat messages (web + Bitbucket thread replies, each linked to \nfinding whose inline comment it answers), and knowledge graph used, with diff/transcript/graph\nblobs pulled from S3 on request.\n graphs_by_id.get(review.…

Bash input={"command":"uv run ruff check --output-format concise $(git status --short | awk '{print $2}' | grep \"\\.py$\") 2>&1 | tail -12; uv run black --diff -q application/services/review_service.py tests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py 2>&1 | head -60"} output={"stdout":"application/services/review_service.py:1189:101: E501 Line too long (102 > 100)\nscripts/export_eval_data.py:3:101: E501 Line too long (102 > 100)\nscripts/export_eval_data.py:52:1: E402 Module level import not at top of file\nscripts/export_eval_data.py:287:101: E501 Line too long (103 > 100)\ntests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py:4:101: E501 Line too long (172 > 100)\ntests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py:17:101: E501 Line too long (101 > 100)\ntests/test_review_noise_controls.py:…

Bash input={"command":"for f in application/routers/integration.py application/services/integration_service.py application/services/review_service.py scripts/export_eval_data.py; do git show HEAD:$f | uv run black --check -q --stdin-filename $f - 2>/dev/null && echo \"$f clean@HEAD\" || echo \"$f dirty@HEAD\"; done; uv run ruff check $(git status --short | awk '{print $2}' | grep \"\\.py$\") 2>&1 | grep -E \"^[A-Z]+[0-9]+|-->\" | head -20"} output={"stdout":"application/routers/integration.py dirty@HEAD\napp/services/integration_service.py dirty@HEAD\napp/services/review_service.py clean@HEAD\nscripts/export_eval_data.py dirty@HEAD","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"grep -B1 -A6 \"^[A-Z][0-9]\\+\\|-->\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/lint.log | grep -E \"^\\S+\\.py:|^[A-Z]+[0-9]+ |-->\" | head -20; for f in application/routers/integration.py application/services/integration_service.py application/services/review_service.py scripts/export_eval_data.py; do git show HEAD:$f > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/orig.py; uv run black --check -q /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/orig.py 2>/dev/null && echo \"$f clean@HEAD\" || echo \"$f dirty@HEAD\"; done"} output={"stdout":"application/routers/integration.py dirty@HEAD\napp/services/integration_service.py dirty@HEAD\napp/services/review_service.py dirty@HEAD\nscripts/export_eval_data.py dirty@HEAD","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"cat.pre-commit-config.yaml | head -30; FILES=$(git status --short | awk '{print $2}' | grep \"\\.py$\"); { uv run ruff check $FILES; echo \"ruff=$?\"; uv run black --check $FILES; echo \"black=$?\"; uv run mypy application; echo \"mypy=$?\"; } > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/lint.log 2>&1; grep -E \"ruff=|black=|mypy=|error|would reformat|Found\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/lint.log | head -30","timeout":400000} output={"stdout":"repositories:\n - repository: https://github.com/astral-sh/ruff-pre-commit\n rev: v0.8.4\n hooks:\n - id: ruff\n arguments: [--fix]\n - id: ruff-format\n\n - repository: https://github.com/psf/black\n rev: 24.10.0\n hooks:\n - id: black\n\n - repository: https://github.com/pre-commit/mirrors-mypy\n rev: v1.13.0\n hooks:\n - id: mypy\n additional_dependencies: [pydantic, types-redis]\n arguments: [--ignore-missing-imports]\nFound 7 errors.\nruff=1\nwould refo…

Bash input={"command":"FILES=$(git status --short | awk '{print $2}' | grep -v \"^frontend/\\|\\.md$\\|\\.txt$\"); (uv run pre-commit run --files $FILES || pre-commit run --files $FILES) > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/precommit.log 2>&1; echo \"exit=$?\"; grep -vE \"^\\s*$\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/precommit.log | tail -40","timeout":400000} output={"stdout":"exit=127\nerror: Failed to spawn: `pre-commit`\n Caused by: No such file or directory (os error 2)\n/bin/bash: line 1: pre-commit: command not found","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\ndef edit(p, pairs):\n s=open(p).read()\n for old,new in pairs:\n assert s.count(old)==1, (p, old[:70], s.count(old))\n s=s.replace(old,new)\n open(p,'w').write(s)\nedit('CLAUDE.md', [\n('''| Review prompt | Every JSON key engines parse stays named in `prompts/review_instruction.txt`; no ceiling on finding count; missing `verdict` normalizes to `comment`, never `approve` | `docs/architecture/review-output.md` |\n| PR comments | `INLINE_C… output={"stdout":".pre-commit-config.yaml\n M CLAUDE.md\n M application/config.py\n M application/integrations/claude_code_client.py\n M application/integrations/codex_client.py\n M application/integrations/prompts/review_instruction.txt\n M application/integrations/review_engine.py\n M application/integrations/review_prompt.py\n M application/models/bitbucket_credential.py\n M application/models/finding.py\n M application/repositories/credential_repository.py\n M application/repositories/finding_repository.py\n M application/routers/integration.py\n M application/schemas.py\n M application/schemas_api.p…

Bash input={"command":"cat >> tests/test_review_noise_controls.py <<'EOF'\n\n\ndef test_the_synthesis_prompt_builds_and_keeps_braces_in_digests_inert():\n \"\"\"Regression: instruction's literal JSON braces made `.format` raise KeyError, so every\n sharded review silently fell back to merged summaries.\"\"\"\n prompt = build_synthesis_prompt(['uses {\"x\": 1}', \"second part\"])\n assert '{\"summary\":' in prompt\n assert 'uses {\"x\": 1}' in prompt\n assert \"{digests}\" not in p… output={"stdout":"97:| Review prompt | Every JSON key engines parse stays named in `prompts/review_instruction.txt`; no ceiling on finding count; missing `verdict` normalizes to `comment`, never `approve` | `docs/architecture/review-output.md` |\n98:| PR comments | `INLINE_COMMENT_MIN_*` are floors, not caps; suppressed finding is still persisted and shown on review page; degraded run posts nothing at PR level; partially covered run names files it missed | same |\n100:| Incremental …

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='application/integrations/review_prompt.py'\ns=open(p).read()\nold=''' `digests` are per-shard summaries already produced, one entry per successful shard. They\n are joined and substituted into instruction with `.format`, which does not re-scan \n substituted value, so braces in model-written summary are inert — same rule every other\n block in this module relies on.'''\nassert s.count(old)==1\ns=s.replace(old,''' `digests` are per-sha… output={"stdout":"tests/test_review_noise_controls.py:28: build_synthesis_prompt,\ntests/test_review_noise_controls.py:478: assert build_synthesis_prompt([\"\", \"b\"]) == build_synthesis_prompt([\"\", \"b\"], bluf=False)\ntests/test_review_noise_controls.py:479: prompt = build_synthesis_prompt([\"part one\", \"part two\"], bluf=True)\nexit=0","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/i…

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"KeyError\" -B12 /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/targeted-3.log | head -30; sed -n 85,100p application/integrations/review_prompt.py"} output={"stdout":"1-/usr/local/lib/python3.12/dist-packages/pytest_asyncio/plugin.py:208: PytestDeprecationWarning: configuration option \"asyncio_default_fixture_loop_scope\" is unset.\n2-The event loop scope for async fixtures will default to fixture caching scope. Future versions of pytest-asyncio will default loop scope for async fixtures to function scope. Set default fixture loop scope explicitly avoid unexpected behavior in future. Valid fixture loop…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='tests/test_review_prompt_composition.py'\ns=open(p).read()\nold=''' \"blocking\",\n \"file_path\",'''\nassert s.count(old)==1\ns=s.replace(old,''' \"blocking\",\n \"evidence\",\n \"file_path\",''')\nopen(p,'w').write(s)\nEOF\nuv run pytest -q --tb=short -p no:cacheprovider tests/test_review_noise_controls.py tests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py tests/test_review_prompt_composition.py > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-blu… output={"stdout":"exit=1\nE KeyError: '\"summary\"'\nFAILED tests/test_review_noise_controls.py::test_bluf_synthesis_rules_sit_before_the_part_summaries","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/tests/test_review_prompt_composition.py","hunks":[{"oldStart":112,"oldLines":6,"newStart":112,"newLines":7,"lines":[" \"suggested_code\","," \"confidence\","," \"blocking\",","+ …

Write input={"file_path":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/tests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py","content":"\"\"\"Migration 0031 is hand-synced to Finding.evidence and BitbucketCredential.bluf_enabled /\npromotion_summary_only.\n\npytest builds SQLite straight from models and never runs Alembic, so column added to model\nbut forgotten in migration passes entire suite and then fails in staging. Same guard as\ntests/test_migration_0030_webhook_integration_status.py.\n\"\"\"\n\nfro… output={"type":"create","filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/tests/test_migration_0031_review_noise_controls.py","content":"\"\"\"Migration 0031 is hand-synced to Finding.evidence and BitbucketCredential.bluf_enabled /\npromotion_summary_only.\n\npytest builds SQLite straight from models and never runs Alembic, so column added to model\nbut forgotten in migration passes entire suite and then fails in staging. Same guard as\ntests/test_migration_0030_webhook_integration_status.py.…

Write input={"file_path":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/tests/test_review_noise_controls.py","content":"\"\"\"Noise controls from documentation/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md (Tahap + B).\n\nEvery rule here bounds what reaches PULL REQUEST; none of them hides finding. Each test that\nwithholds comment also checks finding is still persisted, because that is invariant\n(documentation/architecture/review-output.md) these rules must not regress.\n\n - identical re-review is carried over, neve… output={"type":"create","filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/tests/test_review_noise_controls.py","content":"\"\"\"Noise controls from documentation/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md (Tahap + B).\n\nEvery rule here bounds what reaches PULL REQUEST; none of them hides finding. Each test that\nwithholds comment also checks finding is still persisted, because that is invariant\n(documentation/architecture/review-output.md) these rules must not regress.\n\n - identical re-review is car…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 1,80p tests/test_integration_review_prompt.py; sed -n 255,330p tests/test_integration_review_prompt.py"} output={"stdout":"\"\"\" per-integration custom review prompt: validation, authorization, HTTP, and page.\n\nThree load-bearing tests here:\n - test_rotating_a_token_leaves_the_review_prompt_alone — reason this field is edited on its\n own endpoint than added to add form. `rotate_credential` writes branch_filter\n unconditionally; if prompt had gone on that form it would be wiped on every rotation.\n - test_absent_field_does_not_clear_the_prompt — empty submission c…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 1,90p tests/test_memory_endpoints.py; grep -n \"def test\" tests/test_memory_endpoints.py | head; grep -n \"review-prompt\\|def test\\|panel\" tests/test_integration_review_prompt.py | head -30"} output={"stdout":"\"\"\" memory section of /review-prompt, and its three mutating endpoints: toggle, manual\nreflection trigger, and on-demand content fetch.\n\nAuthority mirrors update_review_prompt/regenerate_webhook_secret exactly: edit-gated (owner or\nadmin) for two mutations, view-gated for read-only content fetch — see\nIntegrationService.set_memory_enabled/trigger_reflection for why.\n\"\"\"\n\nimport json\n\nfrom application.models.repo_memory import MEMORY_TYPE_LONG_TERM\nfrom …

Bash input={"command":"grep -rln \"memory-toggle\\|set_memory_enabled\" tests | head; grep -rn \"def test.*memory.*toggle\\|def test.*set_memory_enabled\" tests | head -3"} output={"stdout":"tests/test_memory_endpoints.py","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"uv run pytest -q --tb=short -p no:cacheprovider tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py tests/test_review_service.py tests/test_review_incremental.py > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/targeted-2.log 2>&1; echo \"exit=$?\"; tail -3 /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/targeted-2.log"} output={"stdout":"exit=0\n warnings.warn(PytestDeprecationWarning(_DEFAULT_FIXTURE_LOOP_SCOPE_UNSET))\n........................................................................ [ 75%]\n........................ [100%]","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='tests/test_review_service.py'\ns=open(p).read()\nold=''' assert \"**Review: worth read**\" in body\n assert \"finding\" in body'''\nassert s.count(old)==1\ns=s.replace(old,''' # stub's only finding is low and non-blocking, so DERIVED verdict is approve\n # (review_aggregate.derive_verdict) whatever engine itself said.\n assert \"**Review: no blocking issues**\" in body\n assert \"finding\" in body''')\nopen(p,'w').write(s)\nEOF\ng… output={"stdout":"application/models/finding.py:106:# Cross-run \"same problem\" tolerance for inline-comment dedup (see `same_problem`). model re-words\napp/models/finding.py:121:def same_problem(new: Any, old: Any) -> bool:\napp/repositories/finding_repository.py:72: Finding.fingerprint.is_not(None),\napp/repositories/finding_repository.py:89: (`finding.same_problem`), not only on exact fingerprint, so it needs fields.\napp/repositories/finding_repository.py:101: …

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 640,675p tests/test_review_service.py"} output={"stdout":" payload = _audit_payload(db_session, \"review_completed\")\n assert payload[\"findings\"] == 0\n assert payload[\"pr_comment_posted\"] is True\n assert payload[\"inline_comments_posted\"] == 0\n assert payload[\"findings_suppressed\"] == 0\n # clean review states its call: stub engine derives \"approve\" from having found nothing.\n assert payload[\"verdict\"] == \"approve\"\n # graph stage ran (stub graph) and is recorded on completion audit row…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\ndef edit(p, pairs):\n s=open(p).read()\n for old,new in pairs:\n assert s.count(old)==1, (p, old[:70], s.count(old))\n s=s.replace(old,new)\n open(p,'w').write(s)\nedit('application/models/finding.py', [\n(''' words. Category is deliberately not required: models re-categorise same problem between\n runs as readily as they re-title it.\n \"\"\"\n if new.fingerprint and old.fingerprint and new.fingerprint == old.fingerprint:\n re… output={"stdout":"Traceback (most recent call last):\n File \"<stdin>\", line 49, in <module>\n File \"<stdin>\", line 4, in edit\nAssertionError: ('tests/test_review_service.py', \" assert '**Review: worth read**' in\", 0)\n666: assert \"**Review: worth read**\" in body","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/models/finding.py","hunks":[{"oldStart":129,"oldLines":8,"newStart":129,"…

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"def test_a_new_finding_is_still_posted_on_the_re_review\" -A28 tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py; grep -n \"def test_legacy_findings_with_no_fingerprint_never_suppress_a_comment\" -A45 tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py"} output={"stdout":"182:def test_a_new_finding_is_still_posted_on_the_re_review(db_session, fake_blobs):\n183- _make_credential(db_session)\n184- _make_review(db_session, event_id=\"evt-1\")\n185- db_session.commit()\n186- bitbucket = CleanBitbucket()\n187- _run(db_session, fake_blobs, \"evt-1\", _engine(_finding()), bitbucket)\n188-\n189- _make_review(db_session, event_id=\"evt-2\")\n190- db_session.commit()\n191- fresh = _finding(title=\"SQL built by string concatenation\", cate…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py'\ns=open(p).read()\nold='''class CleanBitbucket(FakeBitbucket):\n def get_pr_diff(self, workspace, repo_slug, pr_id, credential) -> str:\n return CLEAN_DIFF\n'''\nassert s.count(old)==1\ns=s.replace(old,'''class CleanBitbucket(FakeBitbucket):\n \"\"\"Every fetch is new push: diff differs from last one, so second review is real\n re-review. byte-identical diff would be carried over without posting… output={"stdout":"E AssertionError: assert 1 == 2\nE + where 1 = len([{'content': '**[HIGH · reliability]** Retry loop has no ceiling\\n\\nRetries are unbounded.\\n\\n**Recommendation:** Cap...None, bluf_enabled=False, promotion_summary_only=False), 'file_path': 'application/clients/ledger.py', 'line_number': 42,...}])\nE + where [{'content': '**[HIGH · reliability]** Retry loop has no ceiling\\n\\nRetries are unbounded.\\n\\n**Recommendation:** Cap...None, bluf_enabled=False, promotion_summary_…

Bash input={"command":"for t in test_an_unreadable_conventions_file_degrades_to_no_context test_large_diff_uses_the_primary_model test_degraded_codex_review_still_records_the_model test_findings_present_still_gets_a_pr_level_comment; do grep -c \"$t\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log; done; uv run pytest -q --tb=short -p no:cacheprovider tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py tests/test_review_service.py::test_findings_present_still_gets_a_pr_level_comment 2>&1 | grep -E \"^E |^tests/.*Error|d… output={"stdout":"1\n1\n1\n0\nE AssertionError: assert 1 == 2\nE + where 1 = len([{'content': '**[HIGH · reliability]** Retry loop has no ceiling\\n\\nRetries are unbounded.\\n\\n**Recommendation:** Cap...None, bluf_enabled=False, promotion_summary_only=False), 'file_path': 'application/clients/ledger.py', 'line_number': 42,...}])\nE + where [{'content': '**[HIGH · reliability]** Retry loop has no ceiling\\n\\nRetries are unbounded.\\n\\n**Recommendation:** Cap...None, bluf_enabled=False, promot…

Bash input={"command":"uv run pytest -q --tb=line -p no:cacheprovider tests/test_review_incremental.py tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py tests/test_review_service.py tests/test_review_aggregate.py tests/test_review_prompt_composition.py tests/test_repo_context.py tests/test_claude_code_client.py tests/test_integration_review_prompt.py tests/test_codex_client.py > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/targeted-1.log 2>&1; echo \"exit=$?\"; grep -E \"^(FAILED|ERROR)|passed|failed\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/tar… output={"stdout":"exit=1\nFAILED tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py::test_a_new_finding_is_still_posted_on_the_re_review\nFAILED tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py::test_a_re_review_comments_on_the_new_problem_and_not_the_old_one\nFAILED tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py::test_a_suppressed_finding_does_not_dedup_a_later_one\nFAILED tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py::test_legacy_findings_with_no_fingerprint_never_suppress_a_comment\nFAILED tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py::test_dedup_disabled_restor…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\ndef edit(p, pairs):\n s=open(p).read()\n for old,new,cnt in pairs:\n assert s.count(old)==cnt, (p, old[:70], s.count(old))\n s=s.replace(old,new)\n open(p,'w').write(s)\nedit('tests/test_review_service.py', [\n(''' memory_context: str | None = None,\n tiering_diff: str | None = None,\n ) -> ReviewResult:\n self.repo_dir = repo_dir''',''' memory_context: str | None = None,\n tiering_diff: str | None = None… output={"stdout":" self.result = result\n\n def run_review(self, *arguments, **kwargs) -> ReviewResult:\n return self.result\n\n\ndef _make_review(database, *, event_id: str, pr_id: int = 10, repo_slug: str = \"theropods\"):\n return ReviewEventRepository(database).create(\n event_id=event_id,\n workspace=\"finaccelteam\",\n repo_slug=repo_slug,\n pr_id=pr_id,\n status=STATUS_PENDING,\n )\n\n\ndef _make_credential(database, *, repo_slug: str = \"theropods\"):\n Cre…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 255,275p tests/test_review_service.py; sed -n 55,85p tests/test_repo_context.py; grep -rln \"export_eval_data\" tests; grep -n \"def test\\|comment_id\\|post_inline_comment\" tests/conftest.py | head -20; grep -n \"class FakeBitbucket\" -A40 tests/conftest.py | head -60"} output={"stdout":" self.graph_contexts.append(graph_context)\n self.tiering_diffs.append(kwargs.get(\"tiering_diff\"))\n return self._result or ReviewResult(summary=f\"shard {self.calls}\")\n\n def run_chat(self, repo_dir, context, question):\n return None\n\n def run_synthesis(self, repo_dir, digests):\n self.synthesis_calls += 1\n return \" whole story\", \" good bits\"\n\n\ndef test_a_pr_far_over_the_old_50_file_cap_is_reviewed_not_skipped(\n …

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='frontend/src/components/TriageBar.test.tsx'\ns=open(p).read()\ns=s.replace(''' confidence: null,\n title: \"Example finding\",''',''' confidence: null,\n evidence: null,\n title: \"Example finding\",''',1)\nopen(p,'w').write(s)\np='frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.test.tsx'\ns=open(p).read()\ns+='''\ndescribe(\"IntegrationRepoPanel — PR comment settings\", () => {\n it(\"offers both opt-ins, unchecked by default, to someone who can ed… output={"stdout":"ok","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/frontend/src/components/TriageBar.test.tsx","hunks":[{"oldStart":22,"oldLines":6,"newStart":22,"newLines":7,"lines":[" file_path: \"application/services/example.py\","," line_number: null,"," confidence: null,","+ evidence: null,"," title: \"Example finding\","," reason: \"Because of reasons.\","," impact: null,"]}]},{"…

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"confidence\" -B8 -A8 frontend/src/components/TriageBar.test.tsx | head -40; grep -rn \"credential: {\\|CredentialSummary\" frontend/src --include=*.ts* | grep -v \"lib/types.ts\" | head; grep -rn \"MSW\\|fixtures\" frontend/src/test 2>/dev/null | head -3; ls frontend/src/test"} output={"stdout":"16-function makeFinding(overrides: Partial<Finding>): Finding {\n17- return {\n18- id: 1,\n19- severity: \"medium\",\n20- category: null,\n21- blocking: false,\n22- file_path: \"application/services/example.py\",\n23- line_number: null,\n24: confidence: null,\n25- title: \"Example finding\",\n26- reason: \"Because of reasons.\",\n27- impact: null,\n28- recommendation: \"Do thing.\",\n29- suggested_code: null,\n30- graph_impact: null,\n31- impacte…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\ndef edit(p, pairs):\n s=open(p).read()\n for old,new in pairs:\n assert s.count(old)==1, (p, old[:70], s.count(old))\n s=s.replace(old,new)\n open(p,'w').write(s)\nedit('frontend/src/lib/types.ts', [\n(''' confidence: number | null;\n title: string | null;\n reason: string;''',''' confidence: number | null;\n evidence: \"in_diff\" | \"verified_in_repo\" | \"assumption\" | null;\n title: string | null;\n reason: string;'''),\n(''' memo… output={"stdout":"frontend/src/components/TriageBar.test.tsx","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/frontend/src/lib/types.ts","hunks":[{"oldStart":234,"oldLines":6,"newStart":234,"newLines":7,"lines":[" file_path: string;"," line_number: number | null;"," confidence: number | null;","+ evidence: \"in_diff\" | \"verified_in_repo\" | \"assumption\" | null;"," title: string | null;"," rea…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 1,40p frontend/src/components/FindingCard.tsx; grep -rn \"chip--blocking\" frontend/src --include=*.css | head -3; grep -rn \"chip--\" frontend/src/styles* frontend/src/*.css 2>/dev/null | head; ls frontend/src; grep -rn \"form__check\\|type=\\\"checkbox\\\"\" frontend/src --include=*.tsx | head -5"} output={"stdout":"import { useRef } from \"react\";\nimport type { Finding } from \"../lib/types\";\nimport { CopyButton } from \"./CopyButton\";\nimport { Mdlite } from \"./Mdlite\";\n\nexport function FindingCard({ finding, hidden, current }: { finding: Finding; hidden: boolean; current: boolean }) {\n const codeRef = useRef<HTMLElement>(null);\n\n return (\n <li\n id={`finding-${finding.id}`}\n className={`finding sev--${finding.severity}${current? \" is-current\": \"\"}`}\n ta…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\ndef edit(p, pairs):\n s=open(p).read()\n for old,new in pairs:\n assert s.count(old)==1, (p, old[:70], s.count(old))\n s=s.replace(old,new)\n open(p,'w').write(s)\nedit('scripts/export_eval_data.py', [\n('''\"\"\"Export review context for evaluation/audit: one JSON record per review_event over last N\ndays, joining findings, feedback, and knowledge graph used,''','''\"\"\"Export review context for evaluation/audit: one JSON record per… output={"stdout":"ok","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/scripts/export_eval_data.py","hunks":[{"oldStart":1,"oldLines":5,"newStart":1,"newLines":6,"lines":[" \"\"\"Export review context for evaluation/audit: one JSON record per review_event over last N","-days, joining findings, feedback, and knowledge graph used, with diff/transcript/graph","+days, joining findings, feedback, chat…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\ndef edit(p, pairs):\n s=open(p).read()\n for old,new in pairs:\n assert s.count(old)==1, (p, old[:70], s.count(old))\n s=s.replace(old,new)\n open(p,'w').write(s)\n\nedit('application/services/integration_service.py', [\n('''ACTION_MEMORY_TOGGLED = \"integration.memory_toggled\"\n''','''ACTION_MEMORY_TOGGLED = \"integration.memory_toggled\"\nACTION_COMMENT_SETTINGS_UPDATED = \"integration.comment_settings_updated\"\n'''),\n(''' def trigger_reflect… output={"stdout":"10: 400 IntegrationError — you got something wrong (bad URL, stale id, not your request), or\n58: IntegrationError,\n104: raise IntegrationError(\"No review prompt was submitted.\")\n295: # Caught BEFORE generic IntegrationError below (it is subclass): this actor may\n308: # Caught BEFORE IntegrationError (it is subclass): someone else owns this scope,\napp/config.py:379: default=\"high\", validation_alias=\"INLINE_COMMENT_MIN_SEVERITY\"\napp…

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"^ACTION_\\|^RESOURCE_TYPE\\|^MISSING_CREDENTIAL\" application/services/integration_service.py; sed -n 78,122p application/routers/integration.py; sed -n 280,300p tests/conftest.py 2>/dev/null | head -5; sed -n 60,80p tests/conftest.py"} output={"stdout":"127:RESOURCE_TYPE = \"bitbucket_credential\"\n129:ACTION_CREATED = \"integration.created\"\n130:ACTION_ROTATED = \"integration.token_rotated\"\n131:ACTION_DEACTIVATED = \"integration.deactivated\"\n132:ACTION_REACTIVATED = \"integration.reactivated\"\n133:ACTION_ACCESS_REQUESTED = \"integration.access_requested\"\n134:ACTION_ACCESS_APPROVED = \"integration.access_approved\"\n135:ACTION_ACCESS_DENIED = \"integration.access_denied\"\n136:ACTION_ACCESS_CANCELLED = \"integration.access_ca…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 100,125p tests/test_review_prompt_composition.py && python3 - <<'EOF'\np='application/integrations/prompts/review_instruction.txt'\ns=open(p).read()\ndef rep(old,new):\n global s\n assert s.count(old)==1, old[:60]\n s=s.replace(old,new)\nrep('''5. tests — new or changed behaviour that no test covers.''','''5. tests — new or changed behaviour that no test covers. When missing test is for problem you already report, put it in THAT finding's recommendation instead of fin… output={"stdout":" for key in (\n \"summary\",\n \"strengths\",\n \"verdict\",\n \"risk_level\",\n \"findings\",\n \"severity\",\n \"category\",\n \"title\",\n \"reason\",\n \"impact\",\n \"recommendation\",\n \"suggested_code\",\n \"confidence\",\n \"blocking\",\n \"file_path\",\n \"line_number\",\n \"line_side\",\n \"needs_comment\",\n \"graph_impact\",\n ):\n …

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"in REVIEW_INSTRUCTION\\|in instruction\\|assert.*\\\"\" tests/test_review_prompt_composition.py | head -40; grep -rn \"REVIEW_INSTRUCTION\" tests --include=*.py -l"} output={"stdout":"43: assert build_review_prompt(DIFF) == f\"{REVIEW_INSTRUCTION}\\n\\nDIFF:\\n{DIFF}\"\n56: assert build_review_prompt(DIFF, None, \"\") == baseline\n57: assert build_review_prompt(DIFF, None, \" \\n \") == baseline\n67: assert prompt.index(REVIEW_INSTRUCTION) < prompt.index(CUSTOM) < prompt.index(\"DIFF:\")\n76: assert \"STRICT JSON\" in wrapper_opening\n80: assert build_review_prompt(DIFF, None, f\" {CUSTOM} \") == build_review_prompt(\n91: assert prompt.ind…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='application/integrations/claude_code_client.py'\ns=open(p).read()\nold=''' memory_context=memory_context,\n )\n # Sized on WHOLE review's diff'''\nassert s.count(old)==1\ns=s.replace(old,''' memory_context=memory_context,\n bluf=bluf,\n )\n # Sized on WHOLE review's diff''')\nopen(p,'w').write(s)\nEOF\ngrep -n \"bluf\" application/integrations/claude_code_client.py application/integrations/codex_client.py"} output={"stdout":"application/integrations/claude_code_client.py:162: bluf: bool = False,\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py:201: bluf=bluf,\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py:231: self, repo_dir: str | None, digests: list[str], *, bluf: bool = False\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py:247: build_synthesis_prompt(digests, bluf=bluf),\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py:294: bluf: bool = False,\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py:310: …

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='application/integrations/claude_code_client.py'\ns=open(p).read()\nold=''' memory_context=memory_context,\n tiering_diff=tiering_diff,\n )'''\nassert s.count(old)==1\ns=s.replace(old,''' memory_context=memory_context,\n tiering_diff=tiering_diff,\n bluf=bluf,\n )''')\nlines=s.split('\\n')\ns=s.replace(''' build_synthesis_prompt(digests),''',''' build_synthesis_prompt(diges… output={"stdout":" pr_title,\n pr_description,\n self.settings.pr_description_max_chars,\n # Keyword, never positional: this is fourth optional string in row, and putting\n # ticket's text where repository owner's guidance goes would hand untrusted content\n # authority wrappers exist to withhold from it.\n jira_context=jira_context,\n repo_context=repo_context,\n repo_context_file=repo_cont…

Bash input={"command":"cat > application/integrations/prompts/bluf_instruction.txt <<'EOF'\nWRITING STYLE — BOTTOM LINE UP FRONT (this repository opted in). These rules tighten wording above; they do not change JSON shape or which problems you report.\n- \"title\": problem itself, stated as fact, under 80 characters.\n- \"reason\": exactly ONE sentence, and it starts with consequence — concrete input or condition and what goes wrong (\" None user_id reaches query and returns every row\")… output={"stdout":"application/integrations/codex_client.py:119: bluf: bool = False,\napp/integrations/codex_client.py:236: self, repo_dir: str | None, digests: list[str], *, bluf: bool = False\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py:162: bluf: bool = False,\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py:230: self, repo_dir: str | None, digests: list[str], *, bluf: bool = False\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py:293: bluf: bool = False,\napp/integrations/review_engine.py:51: …

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 282,382p application/integrations/review_prompt.py; grep -n \"SYNTHESIS_INSTRUCTION =\" application/integrations/review_prompt.py; sed -n 140,240p application/integrations/claude_code_client.py; sed -n 270,300p application/integrations/claude_code_client.py; sed -n 234,260p application/integrations/codex_client.py; grep -rn \"len(.*default_prompt_sections\\|sections) ==\" tests | head"} output={"stdout":"def default_prompt_sections() -> tuple[PromptSection,...]:\n \"\"\" built-in prompt, in order it is assembled, for rendering read-only.\n\n Built from same module-level constants engines send, so page cannot describe \n prompt that differs from one in use. Chat is deliberately absent: this page documents how \n pull request gets REVIEWED.\n \"\"\"\n return (\n PromptSection(\n key=\"review_instruction\",\n label=…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='application/services/review_service.py'\ns=open(p).read()\ndef rep(old,new,count=1):\n global s\n assert s.count(old)==count, (old[:80], s.count(old))\n s=s.replace(old,new)\n\nrep('''from application.models.finding import SEVERITIES, Finding, finding_fingerprint, severity_rank''',\n'''from application.models.bitbucket_credential import is_promotion_pr\nfrom application.models.finding import (\n EVIDENCE_ASSUMPTION,\n SEVERITIES,\n Finding,\n finding_fingerprint,\n is_t… output={"stdout":"23: def get_by_id(self, review_id: int) -> ReviewEvent | None:","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[],"moreFiles":1,"changedFiles":["/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/services/review_service.py"]}}

Bash input={"command":"grep -rn \"_already_commented\\|_previously_posted_fingerprints\\|_clears_thresholds\\|_inline_comment_body\\|_summary_comment_body\\|_synthesize\\|_post_inline_comments\\|PostingOutcome\" tests"} output={"stdout":"tests/test_review_service.py:331:def test_a_sharded_review_calls_the_engine_once_per_shard_then_synthesizes(\ntests/test_review_aggregate.py:163:def test_synthesized_prose_wins_over_the_merge_and_absence_falls_back():","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"grep -rn \"_already_commented\\|_previously_posted_fingerprints\\|_clears_thresholds\\|_inline_comment_body\\|_summary_comment_body\\|_synthesize\\|_post_inline_comments\\|PostingOutcome\" tests | grep -v \"^tests/.*:.*#\" | awk -F: '{print $1}' | sort | uniq -c; grep -rn \"_post_inline_comments\\|_already_commented\\|_previously_posted\" application | grep -v \"review_service.py\""} output={"stdout":" 1 tests/test_review_aggregate.py\n 1 tests/test_review_service.py","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"returnCodeInterpretation":"No matches found","noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='application/services/review_aggregate.py'\ns=open(p).read()\ns=s.replace(''' - verdict WORST any shard returned. rule, never judgement call: one shard asking for\n changes is review asking for changes, and no amount of clean shards outvotes it.''',''' - verdict WORST any shard returned. rule, never judgement call: one shard asking for\n changes is review asking for changes, and no amount of clean shards outvote… output={"stdout":"ok","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/services/review_aggregate.py","hunks":[{"oldStart":13,"oldLines":6,"newStart":13,"newLines":8,"lines":[" ordered worst-severity-first. Nothing is dropped for being numerous."," - verdict WORST any shard returned. rule, never judgement call: one shard asking for"," changes is review asking…

Read input={"file_path":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/tests/test_review_incremental.py","offset":1,"limit":310} output={"type":"text","file":{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/tests/test_review_incremental.py","content":"\"\"\"application/services/review_incremental.py + its wiring: re-review only what changed since last time.\n\nTwo things are under test and they matter for opposite reasons. planner must NARROW work\nwhen it can — that is whole point, and without it removing size caps multiplies cost of\nevery re-push by shard count. And it must FALL BACK to full review on every un…

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"commit\\|def test\" tests/test_review_incremental.py | head -40"} output={"stdout":"70:def _make_review(database, event_id: str, *, commit_hash: str, status: str = STATUS_PENDING):\n77: commit_hash=commit_hash,\n94: def __init__(self, event_id, commit_hash, status=STATUS_COMPLETED, diff_key=\"k\", rid=1):\n96: self.commit_hash = commit_hash\n102:def test_only_the_file_whose_diff_changed_is_planned_for_review():\n116:def test_a_first_review_is_always_full():\n120:def test_a_previous_review_that_did_not_complete_is_not_a_baseline():\n132:def test_an_unreadab…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\np='application/services/review_incremental.py'\ns=open(p).read()\ns=s.replace('''DID change are deliberately NOT carried: they are re-derived, so problem author fixed\ndisappears on its own instead of haunting pull request.\n\"\"\"''','''DID change are deliberately NOT carried: they are re-derived, so problem author fixed\ndisappears on its own instead of haunting pull request.\n\nA re-review whose FULL diff is byte-identical to previous c… output={"stdout":"","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/services/review_incremental.py","hunks":[{"oldStart":27,"oldLines":6,"newStart":27,"newLines":13,"lines":[" page keeps showing whole pull request instead of only last delta. Findings on files that"," DID change are deliberately NOT carried: they are re-derived, so problem author fixed"," disappears on its own instead …

Bash input={"command":"sed -i 's/^from application.models.finding import CATEGORIES, SEVERITIES$/from application.models.finding import CATEGORIES, EVIDENCE_ASSUMPTION, EVIDENCE_LEVELS, SEVERITIES/' application/schemas.py && python3 - <<'EOF'\np='application/services/credential_resolver.py'\ns=open(p).read()\ns=s.replace(''' custom_review_prompt=cred.custom_review_prompt,\n )''',''' custom_review_prompt=cred.custom_review_prompt,\n bluf_enabled=bool(cred.bluf_enabled),\n promotion_summary_only=bool(cred.pro… output={"stdout":"done","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/schemas.py","hunks":[{"oldStart":3,"oldLines":7,"newStart":3,"newLines":7,"lines":[" from pydantic import BaseModel, ConfigDict, Field, model_validator"," "," from application.models.configuration import CONFIG_TYPES, ConfigType","-from application.models.finding import CATEGORIES, SEVERITIES","+from application.models.finding import CATEGORIES, EVIDENCE_ASSUMPTI…

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"^from\\|^import\" application/schemas.py && python3 - <<'EOF'\np='application/schemas.py'\ns=open(p).read()\ns=s.replace(''' token: str\n custom_review_prompt: str | None = None\n''',''' token: str\n custom_review_prompt: str | None = None\n # Per-repo comment-style opt-ins (bitbucket_credentials, migration 0031), off same row for\n # same reason as custom_review_prompt. False on every construction that predates them.\n bluf_enabled: bool = False\n promotion… output={"stdout":"3:from pydantic import BaseModel, ConfigDict, Field, model_validator\n5:from application.models.configuration import CONFIG_TYPES, ConfigType\n6:from application.models.finding import CATEGORIES, SEVERITIES\n7:from application.models.review_event import RISK_LEVELS, VERDICT_COMMENT, VERDICTS\n8:from application.models.user import ROLE_USER\n6:from application.models.finding import CATEGORIES, SEVERITIES\n202: return value if value in SEVERITIES else \"info\"","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected…

Bash input={"command":"python3 - <<'EOF'\nimport re\np='application/models/finding.py'\ns=open(p).read()\ns=s.replace('''def severity_rank(severity: str | None) -> int:''','''# How reviewer knows finding is real (review_instruction.txt defines each). Only first two\n# may block merge or earn inline comment: `assumption` depends on code reviewer could\n# not see, so it is persisted and shown on review page but never posted inline and never\n# blocking. NULL (\"did not say\" — every pre-003… output={"stdout":"152:_TEST_PATH = re.compile(\n153- r\"(^|/)(tests?|__tests__|spec)/|(^|/)test_[^/]*$|_test\\.[^/]+$|\\.(test|spec)\\.[^/]+$\",\n154- re.IGNORECASE,\n155-)","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"bashEditDiff":{"files":[{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/models/finding.py","hunks":[{"oldStart":43,"oldLines":6,"newStart":43,"newLines":17,"lines":[" )"," "," ","+# How reviewer knows finding is real (review_instruction.txt def…

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"updated_at\" migrations/versions/0020_config_table.py application/models/base.py | head; sed -n 1,40p tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py; sed -n 1,120p tests/test_review_service.py"} output={"stdout":"migrations/versions/0020_config_table.py:40: \"updated_at\",\napp/models/base.py:3:Every table: id BIGINT IDENTITY + CHECK (id > 0); created_at/updated_at TIMESTAMPTZ\napp/models/base.py:27: updated_at: Mapped[datetime] = mapped_column(\n\"\"\"Cross-run inline-comment dedup: re-review never reposts comment PR already carries.\n\nThe severity/confidence floors bound WHICH of one review's findings are worth comment and have\nno memory (and there is no per-review …

Write input={"file_path":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/migrations/versions/0031_review_noise_controls.py","content":"\"\"\"findings.evidence + bitbucket_credentials.bluf_enabled/promotion_summary_only + \nINLINE_COMMENT_MIN_SEVERITY floor raised to high — noise controls from\ndocs/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md (Tahap + B).\n\nPostgres dialect, hand-written against application/models/finding.py and application/models/bitbucket_credential.py\n— no autogenerate, per CLAUDE.md. tests/test_migration_00… output={"type":"create","filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/migrations/versions/0031_review_noise_controls.py","content":"\"\"\"findings.evidence + bitbucket_credentials.bluf_enabled/promotion_summary_only + \nINLINE_COMMENT_MIN_SEVERITY floor raised to high — noise controls from\ndocs/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md (Tahap + B).\n\nPostgres dialect, hand-written against application/models/finding.py and application/models/bitbucket_credential.py\n— no autogenerate, per CLAUDE.md. tests/te…

Bash input={"command":"cat migrations/versions/0030_webhook_integration_status.py; grep -n \"memory_enabled\" -B3 -A10 migrations/versions/0022_repo_memory.py | head -30"} output={"stdout":"\"\"\"webhook_deliveries.repo_id + bitbucket_credentials.last_webhook_received_at — surfaces\nwhether repository's Bitbucket webhook has been configured and is delivering events.\n\nPostgres dialect (DATABASE_URL is postgresql+psycopg; compose runs postgres:16), hand-written\nagainst application/models/webhook_delivery.py and application/models/bitbucket_credential.py — no autogenerate,\nper CLAUDE.md.\n\nADDITIVE ONLY, no backfill:\n - webhook_deliveries.repo_id is NULL for every row written b…

AskUserQuestion input={"answers":{" plan is in documentation/improver/eval-noise-bluf-improvement-plan.md. Summary: identical re-reviews carry previous review and post nothing; inline dedup matches on file + line ±5 or similar title; `tests` findings aren't inline unless file is test file; new `evidence` field, where assumption findings become non-blocking and never inline; prompt bans and confidence rubric; blocking findings bypass severity floor, and default floor moves to high (seeded configuration includ… output={"questions":[{"header":"Approve","multiSelect":false,"options":[{"description":"Implement plan as written, with tests, then commit locally.","label":"Approve — implement"},{"description":"Tell me what to change in plan first (use Other to type it).","label":"Request changes"}],"question":" plan is in documentation/improver/eval-noise-bluf-improvement-plan.md. Summary: identical re-reviews carry previous review and post nothing; inline dedup matches on file + line ±5 or similar title; `t…

ToolSearch input={"query":"select:ExitPlanMode","max_results":1} output={"matches":["ExitPlanMode"],"query":"select:ExitPlanMode","total_deferred_tools":92}

Bash input={"command":"grep -E \"^[0-9]+ (failed|passed)|=.*(passed|failed)\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log; grep -B2 \"^exit=\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log | head; grep -m3 -A15 \"ERROR at setup\\|short test summary\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log | head -20"} output={"stdout":"ERROR tests/test_jira_context.py::test_the_transparency_page_documents_the_block\nERROR tests/test_jira_context.py::test_the_preview_does_not_invent_a_ticket\nexit=1\n=========================== short test summary info ============================\nFAILED tests/test_admin_configs.py::test_the_page_lists_existing_configs - as...\nFAILED tests/test_admin_configs.py::test_the_page_offers_the_add_form_when_there_are_no_configs\nFAILED tests/test_admin_configs.py::test_the_add_config_card_…

Bash input={"command":"grep -E \"passed|failed\" /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log | tail -2; grep -c '^ERROR' /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log"} output={"stdout":"FAILED tests/test_chat_async.py::test_failed_turn_renders_a_visible_retry_message\nERROR tests/test_jira_context.py::test_a_failed_fetch_leaves_the_review_without_context\n58","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Bash input={"command":"tail -3 /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log; grep -c '^FAILED' /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log; grep '^FAILED' /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log | sed 's/::.*//' | sort | uniq -c"} output={"stdout":"ERROR tests/test_jira_context.py::test_the_transparency_page_documents_the_block\nERROR tests/test_jira_context.py::test_the_preview_does_not_invent_a_ticket\nexit=1\n135\n 8 FAILED tests/test_admin_configs.py\n 29 FAILED tests/test_admin_events.py\n 1 FAILED tests/test_admin_users.py\n 13 FAILED tests/test_agent_status.py\n 3 FAILED tests/test_analytics.py\n 1 FAILED tests/test_branding.py\n 2 FAILED tests/test_chat_async.py\n 1 FAILED tests/test…

<task-notification>
<task-id>b10jbn105</task-id>
<tool-use-id>toolu_011vJsXjXrzTf6zudRSLKaE1</tool-use-id>
<output-file>/tmp/claude-0/-home-etc-claude-code-work-osprey/52012d37-364a-455d-a224-f13925c4fd41/tasks/b10jbn105.output</output-file>
<status>completed</status>
<summary>Background command "(which uv &amp;&amp; uv run pytest -q --tb=no -p no:cacheprovider &gt; /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log 2&gt;&amp;1; echo "exit=$?" &gt;&gt; /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log)" completed (exit code 0)</summary>
</task-notification>

Write input={"file_path":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/docs/improver/eval-noise-bluf-improvement-plan.md","content":"# Improvement Plan — PR agent eval Tahap + B (less noise, evidence gate, per-repo BLUF)\n\n## Goal\n\nCut PR noise on data in `docs/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md` without hiding any\nfinding, and add to-the-point (BLUF) comment style that repository owner can switch on per repository\n(default off) for trial.\n\n- Tahap: usulan 1 (identical re-review), 2 (identity not tied … output={"type":"create","filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/docs/improver/eval-noise-bluf-improvement-plan.md","content":"# Improvement Plan — PR agent eval Tahap + B (less noise, evidence gate, per-repo BLUF)\n\n## Goal\n\nCut PR noise on data in `docs/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md` without hiding any\nfinding, and add to-the-point (BLUF) comment style that repository owner can switch on per repository\n(default off) for trial.\n\n- Tahap: usulan 1 (identical re-review), 2 (ide…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 140,160p.environment.example; grep -n \"blocking\\|confidence\\|chip\" frontend/src/components/FindingCard.tsx | head -20; grep -n \"interface Finding\\b\" - 20 frontend/src/lib/types.ts"} output={"stdout":"# --- Runtime configuration (database-backed) ---\n# Non-secret, tunable variables stored in `configs` table and editable via admin UI\n# (/admin/configs). Loaded into memory + Redis cache on application startup. All changes are audited.\n# Examples: rate limits, timeouts, model names, feature flags, review output settings, etc.\n# Configure via admin screen after application starts. Sensible defaults are applied if not set.\n\n# --- Review sharding + incremental review ---\n# NO SIZE REFUSES…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 20,50p application/services/credential_resolver.py; grep -rn \"ResolvedCredential(\" application | grep -v \"^application/schemas.py\"; grep -n \"INLINE_COMMENT\".environment.example; grep -rn \"def run_synthesis\" tests | head; grep -rln \"blocking\" frontend/src/routes frontend/src/components | head; tail -5 /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log"} output={"stdout":"def resolve_credential(database: Session, workspace: str, repo_slug: str) -> ResolvedCredential:\n \"\"\" active credential for exactly this repository.\n\n There is no workspace-wide fallback (removed with scope itself in migration 0010): \n repository without its own active credential is not integrated, and saying so beats reviewing/\n replying with neighbouring repository's token.\n\n Every credential is repository Access Token (0014), so decrypted token is all \n …

Bash input={"command":"grep -rn \"def run_review\" - 3 tests | grep -c \"kwargs\"; grep -rn \"def run_review\" tests | wc -l; grep -rn \"def run_review\" - 14 tests | grep -v kwargs | grep \"def run_review\" | head; grep -n \"def run_synthesis\" - 3 application/integrations/*.py; grep -n \"def latest_for_pr\\|def previous_for_pr\" - 18 application/repositories/review_event_repository.py | head -40"} output={"stdout":"7\n9\ntests/test_review_service.py:71: def run_review(\ntests/test_repo_context.py:61: def run_review(\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py:228: def run_synthesis(self, repo_dir: str | None, digests: list[str]) -> tuple[str, str] | None:\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py-229- \"\"\"(summary, strengths) for review that was sharded across several calls, or None.\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py-230-\napp/integrations/claude_code_client.py-231- No…

Bash input={"command":"cat application/integrations/review_engine.py; sed -n 100,215p application/integrations/codex_client.py; sed -n 872,905p application/services/review_service.py; sed -n 383,402p application/integrations/review_prompt.py"} output={"stdout":"\"\"\"Which engine reviews, chosen by REVIEW_ENGINE.\n\n`ReviewEngine` is surface both providers implement and type services hold. It is \nProtocol than base class so `ClaudeCodeClient` needed no change to satisfy it, and so \ntest can still inject plain fake (several already do).\n\n`run_synthesis` is newest of three and is deliberately OPTIONAL in practice: it writes \noverall summary of review that was sharded across several calls, and `ReviewS…

Bash input={"command":"(which uv && uv run pytest -q --tb=no -p no:cacheprovider > /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log 2>&1; echo \"exit=$?\" >> /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf/pytest-baseline.log)","run_in_background":true} output={"stdout":"","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false,"backgroundTaskId":"b10jbn105"}

Bash input={"command":"grep -rn \"inline_comment_min_severity\\|INLINE_COMMENT_MIN_SEVERITY\" tests | head -20; grep -n \"def _cfg\" - 25 application/config.py | head -40; sed -n 1,60p tests/conftest.py; grep -rn \"test_migration_0030\" -l tests | head -2; sed -n 1,50p tests/test_migration_0030_webhook_integration_status.py"} output={"stdout":"tests/test_inline_comment_dedup.py:252: monkeypatch.setattr(service.settings, \"inline_comment_min_severity\", \"critical\")\ntests/test_review_service.py:987: _override(monkeypatch, service, inline_comment_min_severity=\"high\")\n698: def _cfg(key: str, default: Any) -> Any:\n699- \"\"\"Effective value for `key`: DB-backed `configs` table if active row\n700- exists there (`ConfigService.get_cached`), else `default` unchanged.\n701-\n702- Import is…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 1,60p frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.tsx; sed -n 175,295p frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.tsx; sed -n 344,416p application/routers/integration.py; sed -n 150,200p application/routers/integration.py; cat frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.test.tsx | head -92"} output={"stdout":"import { useState } from \"react\";\nimport { api } from \"../lib/api\";\nimport { useRequestChrome } from \"../lib/useRequestChrome\";\nimport { useConfirm } from \"../lib/useConfirm\";\nimport { BranchChips } from \"./BranchChips\";\nimport { WebhookSecretReveal } from \"./WebhookSecretReveal\";\nimport { CopyButton } from \"./CopyButton\";\nimport { formatDateTime } from \"../lib/format\";\nimport type { IntegrationRepoResponse } from \"../lib/types\";\n\nexport function Integratio…

Bash input={"command":"wc -l frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.tsx frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.test.tsx; grep -n \"custom\\|branch\\|postForm\\|api\\.\\|onChange\\|function \\|canEdit\\|can_edit\" frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.tsx | head -60; grep -n \"@router\\|def \" application/routers/integration.py | head -60"} output={"stdout":" 381 frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.tsx\n 92 frontend/src/components/IntegrationRepoPanel.test.tsx\n 473 total\n11:export function IntegrationRepoPanel({\n22: const [branches, setBranches] = useState(cred.branches);\n23: const [prompt, setPrompt] = useState(cred.custom_review_prompt?? \"\");\n29: async function post(path: string, body: Record<string, string>) {\n31: api.postForm<IntegrationRepoResponse>(`/integration/${credentialId}/${path}`, {\n103: …

AskUserQuestion input={"answers":{"'Inline only for high/critical or blocking' — how should this land?":"Also change defaults to high now","BLUF scope when repository turns it on — which parts switch?":"Inline comment format, Prompt addendum (BLUF writing rules)","Promotion PRs as per-repo setting — which shape?":"Per-repo toggle, default OFF, fixed patterns","Where should per-repo toggles (BLUF format, promotion summary-only) live in UI?":"Integration repository panel"},"questions":[{"header":"Promo shape","multiSel… output={"questions":[{"header":"Promo shape","multiSelect":false,"options":[{"description":"bitbucket_credentials.promotion_summary_only BOOLEAN NOT NULL DEFAULT true. Promotion = source AND dest both match release/*, main, master (case-insensitive). Owners can switch it off per repository. Applies to all repositories immediately.","label":"Per-repo toggle, default ON, fixed patterns (Recommended)"},{"description":"Same column, default false — trial on selected repositories first, like BLUF.","label":"Per-repo toggle, def…

AskUserQuestion input={"answers":{"Usulan 1 — re-review whose reviewable diff is byte-identical to last COMPLETED review: what should it do?":"Carry all, post nothing (Recommended)","Usulan 2 — when should new finding count as 'already commented' by earlier review of same PR?":"File + line ±5 OR similar title (Recommended)","Usulan 4 — how should promotion PRs (release/* → main/master and back) be recognised for summary-only (no inline comments)?":"Per-repo column","Usulan 5 — finding with evidence =… output={"questions":[{"header":"Identical","multiSelect":false,"options":[{"description":"No engine call. Copy every finding plus verdict/summary/risk from last review onto new row, mark it COMPLETED, post no inline and no PR-level comment. Same commit but different diff (base branch moved) → normal incremental review over changed files.","label":"Carry all, post nothing (Recommended)"},{"description":"Same as above, but post one PR comment like 'No code changes since last review'.","…

Write input={"file_path":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/docs/improver/eval-noise-bluf-assessment.md","content":"# Assessment — PR agent eval: Tahap + B (noise reduction, evidence gate, optional BLUF)\n\nSource: `docs/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md` — Tahap (usulan 1, 2, 3, 4, 7) and\nTahap B (usulan 5, 6, 8, BLUF format, `chat_messages` export). BLUF must be per-repo opt-in,\ndefault off.\n\nKnowledge graph: used — COMPARE against 2026-09-06 baseline (`59f6423` → `e0cf23c`); drift i… output={"type":"create","filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/docs/improver/eval-noise-bluf-assessment.md","content":"# Assessment — PR agent eval: Tahap + B (noise reduction, evidence gate, optional BLUF)\n\nSource: `docs/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md` — Tahap (usulan 1, 2, 3, 4, 7) and\nTahap B (usulan 5, 6, 8, BLUF format, `chat_messages` export). BLUF must be per-repo opt-in,\ndefault off.\n\nKnowledge graph: used — COMPARE against 2026-09-06 baseline (`59f6423` → `e0c…

Bash input={"command":"ls documentation/improver | grep -i \"eval\\|bluf\\|noise\"; ls migrations/versions | tail -2; sed -n 70,100p application/schemas_api.py; grep -n \"normalized_verdict\\|VERDICT\" application/integrations/claude_code_client.py application/integrations/codex_client.py | head; mkdir -p /tmp/improver-eval-noise-bluf; echo ok"} output={"stdout":"0030_webhook_integration_status.py\n__pycache__\n \"role\": user.role,\n \"full_name\": user.full_name,\n \"last_login_at\": to_jsonable(user.last_login_at),\n \"created_at\": to_jsonable(user.created_at),\n }\n\n\ndef finding_json(finding: Any) -> dict[str, Any]:\n \"\"\"Explicit field list for `Finding` row — trims internal pipeline bookkeeping\n (`fingerprint`, `bitbucket_comment_id`, `posted`, `needs_comment`, `line_side`,\n `review_event_…

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"INLINE\\|SUMMARY\" migrations/versions/0023_seed_configs.py; cat application/integrations/prompts/synthesis_instruction.txt; sed -n 360,410p application/config.py; sed -n 880,930p application/config.py; grep -rn \"def finding_json\\|\\\"blocking\\\"\" application --include=*.py | head; ls tests | grep -i \"review\\|export\\|finding\\|incremental\\|aggregate\\|integration\\|prompt\""} output={"stdout":"63: (\"INLINE_COMMENT_MIN_SEVERITY\", \"info\", \"string\", \"Lowest severity that earns inline PR comment.\"),\n64: (\"INLINE_COMMENT_MAX_PER_REVIEW\", \"10\", \"int\", \"Maximum inline comments posted per review.\"),\n65: (\"INLINE_COMMENT_MIN_CONFIDENCE\", \"0.0\", \"float\", \"Confidence floor for inline comment (0 = no floor).\"),\n66: (\"INLINE_COMMENT_CROSS_RUN_DEDUP_ENABLED\", \"true\", \"bool\", \"Suppress re-posting finding earlier review of same PR al…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 100,114p application/integrations/review_prompt.py; sed -n 215,282p application/integrations/review_prompt.py; sed -n 36,60p application/schemas.py; sed -n 775,872p application/services/review_service.py; grep -n \"custom_review_prompt\\|custom_instruction\" application/services/credential_resolver.py application/integrations/codex_client.py application/integrations/claude_code_client.py application/integrations/review_engine.py"} output={"stdout":"PREVIEW_PR_DESCRIPTION_PLACEHOLDER = \"< pull request description is inserted here>\"\n\n\ndef _custom_block(custom_instruction: str | None) -> str:\n \"\"\" repository's own guidance, wrapped — or \"\" when it has none.\n\n Empty string for NULL/blank is whole backward-compatibility story: repository that sets no\n guidance gets prompt byte-identical to one it got before this feature existed.\n \"\"\"\n text = (custom_instruction or \"\").strip()\n if no…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 60,120p application/models/chat_message.py; cat scripts/export_eval_data.py; sed -n 1,80p application/integrations/review_prompt.py; grep -n \"def \" application/integrations/review_prompt.py"} output={"stdout":" content: Mapped[str] = mapped_column(Text, nullable=False)\n # real users.id, NULL for every turn with no human author — which is every assistant\n # turn ( bot has no users row), plus historical rows whose crc32 id could not be\n # recovered. user_email carries attribution UI renders.\n user_id: Mapped[int | None] = mapped_column(BigInteger, ForeignKey(\"users.id\"), nullable=True)\n user_email: Mapped[str] = mapped_column(String(255), nullabl…

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"branch\\|title\\|Column\\|mapped_column\" application/models/review_event.py | head -40; cat application/repositories/finding_repository.py | sed -n 1,91p; sed -n 1,60p application/models/chat_message.py"} output={"stdout":"7:from sqlalchemy.orm import Mapped, mapped_column\n90: event_id: Mapped[str] = mapped_column(String(36), nullable=False, unique=True)\n91: workspace: Mapped[str] = mapped_column(String(255), nullable=False)\n92: repo_slug: Mapped[str] = mapped_column(String(255), nullable=False)\n93: pr_id: Mapped[int] = mapped_column(BigInteger, nullable=False)\n94: pr_title: Mapped[str | None] = mapped_column(String(1024), nullable=True)\n99: pr_description: Mapped[str | None] = m…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 160,292p application/schemas.py; grep -n \"FindingInput\\|ReviewResult(\\|verdict\\|def _parse\\|def parse\\|confidence\\|blocking\" application/integrations/codex_client.py application/integrations/claude_code_client.py application/integrations/review_prompt.py | head -40"} output={"stdout":" author_label: str\n file_path: str | None = None\n line_number: int | None = None\n\n @property\n def is_inline(self) -> bool:\n return self.file_path is not None\n\n\nclass FindingInput(BaseModel):\n \"\"\" finding produced by review engine, before persistence.\n\n Every field added for senior-review format defaults to None, so payload carrying none of\n them parses into exactly object engines produced before they existed. That is wh…

Bash input={"command":"cat frontend/src/routes/ReviewPromptPage.tsx; sed -n 315,365p frontend/src/lib/types.ts; grep -n \"memory\\|Memory\" frontend/src/lib/api.ts; ls frontend/src/routes | grep -i test; grep -rln \"ReviewPromptPage\" frontend/src"} output={"stdout":"import { useEffect, useState } from \"react\";\nimport { useSearchParams } from \"react-router-dom\";\nimport { api } from \"../lib/api\";\nimport { useRequestChrome } from \"../lib/useRequestChrome\";\nimport { useConfirm } from \"../lib/useConfirm\";\nimport type { MemoryContentResponse, ReviewPromptResponse } from \"../lib/types\";\n\nexport function ReviewPromptPage() {\n const [searchParams] = useSearchParams();\n const [data, setData] = useState<ReviewPromptResponse | null>(nu…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 540,640p application/routers/integration.py; sed -n 900,975p application/services/integration_service.py; sed -n 125,150p application/repositories/credential_repository.py; sed -n 170,200p application/schemas_api.py; sed -n 95,135p application/services/memory_service.py; grep -ln memory_enabled migrations/versions/*.py"} output={"stdout":" # and shaped to exactly columns that type declares ( ORM dump of \n # full row would leak content/workspace/repo_slug and use `memory_type`,\n # not `type`, as key).\n \"memory_rows\": [\n {\n \"type\": memory_type,\n \"entry_count\": row.entry_count,\n \"char_count\": row.char_count,\n \"updated_at\": …

Bash input={"command":"grep -rn \"memory_enabled\" --include=*.py application scripts | grep -v \"^application/models/bitbucket_credential.py\"; grep -rn \"memory_enabled\\|memoryEnabled\" frontend/src | head -30"} output={"stdout":"application/repositories/credential_repository.py:135: def set_memory_enabled(self, row: BitbucketCredential, enabled: bool) -> BitbucketCredential:\napp/repositories/credential_repository.py:142: row.memory_enabled = enabled\napp/routers/integration.py:598: service.set_memory_enabled(\napp/config.py:537: # feature, and single per-repo toggle (bitbucket_credentials.memory_enabled) with no\napp/config.py:540: # when THIS is true AND its own memory_enabled column is tru…

Bash input={"command":"sed -n 1,200p application/schemas.py | grep -n \"\" | sed -n '1,200p' | grep -v \"^\\s*$\" | head -0; grep -n \"class \\|def \\|verdict\\|confidence\\|blocking\" application/schemas.py | head -80"} output={"stdout":"11:class Actor(BaseModel):\n36:class ResolvedCredential(BaseModel):\n61:class ParsedWebhook(BaseModel):\n82:class ImpactedCaller(BaseModel):\n85: `confidence` comes straight from graph's resolution tier (1.0 direct import … 0.55\n86: suffix match) and is carried all way into PR comment. low-confidence edge is\n93: confidence: float = 1.0\n97:class TouchedFunction(BaseModel):\n108:class GraphImpact(BaseModel):\n122: def has_impact(self) -> bool:\n125: def c…

Read input={"file_path":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/services/review_service.py","offset":1,"limit":580} output={"type":"text","file":{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/services/review_service.py","content":"\"\"\"Review orchestration — worker's unit of work for one review event.\n\nSequence: load event -> resolve+decrypt credential -> fetch diff (S3) -> [checkout repository: \nrepo's cached clone refreshed, else fresh clone] ->\n[build/reuse knowledge graph + compute dependency impact] -> [resolve cited Jira ticket] ->\nrun Claude Code -> persist findings\n+ transcript (S3) -> post…

Read input={"file_path":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/services/review_service.py","offset":950,"limit":482} output={"type":"text","file":{"filePath":"/home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/app/services/review_service.py","content":"\n return _read\n\n # ---- incremental review ----\n def _incremental_plan(self, review: ReviewEvent, needs_review_diff: str) -> IncrementalPlan:\n \"\"\"What this review must look at, given what last one already covered.\n\n Never raises and never narrows on guess: `plan_incremental` resolves every uncertainty\n to full review, and …

Bash input={"command":"grep -n \"def \\|incremental\\|fingerprint\\|carried\\|_inline_comment_body\\|min_severity\\|min_confidence\\|verdict\\|source_branch\\|dest_branch\" application/services/review_service.py | head -150"} output={"stdout":"34:from application.models.finding import SEVERITIES, Finding, finding_fingerprint, severity_rank\n73:from application.services.review_incremental import IncrementalPlan\n74:from application.services.review_incremental import plan as plan_incremental\n95:# How each verdict reads in PR-level comment's headline.\n122:def _dependency_impact_section(finding) -> str:\n153:def _severity_headline(finding: Finding) -> str:\n164:def _inline_comment_body(finding: Finding, review_url: str) -> str:\n194:def _coverag…

Read input={"file_path":"/root/.claude/projects/-home-etc-claude-code-work-osprey/47805a7a-d276-4199-a22a-699ff812dce1/tool-results/bc7grpdp9.txt"} output={"type":"text","file":{"filePath":"/root/.claude/projects/-home-etc-claude-code-work-osprey/47805a7a-d276-4199-a22a-699ff812dce1/tool-results/bc7grpdp9.txt","content":"\"\"\"Review only what changed since this pull request was last reviewed.\n\nA pull request is reviewed once per push. Before this module, every push re-reviewed ENTIRE\ndiff from scratch: 60-file pull request pushed five times cost five full reviews, and\n`INLINE_COMMENT_CROSS_RUN_DEDUP_ENABLED` only stopped same COMMEN…

Bash input={"command":"cat application/models/config.py application/models/bitbucket_credential.py; sed -n 1,80p application/services/config_service.py; grep -n \"INLINE_COMMENT\\|SUMMARY_COMMENT\\|REVIEW_INCREMENTAL\\|REVIEW_SHARD\" application/config.py"} output={"stdout":"\"\"\"Runtime configuration table for non-secret environment variables.\n\nLoaded into memory on application startup via ConfigService.load_all(). Editable via admin UI.\nType-hinted to support bool, int, float, string values.\n\"\"\"\n\nfrom enum import StrEnum\n\nfrom sqlalchemy import CheckConstraint, String\nfrom sqlalchemy.orm import Mapped, mapped_column\n\nfrom application.database import Base\nfrom application.models.base import IdMixin, TimestampMixin\n\n\nclass ConfigType(StrEnum):\n \"\"\"Type hint f…

Bash input={"command":"cat application/services/review_incremental.py application/models/finding.py application/integrations/prompts/review_instruction.txt application/services/review_aggregate.py"} output={"stdout":"\"\"\"Review only what changed since this pull request was last reviewed.\n\nA pull request is reviewed once per push. Before this module, every push re-reviewed ENTIRE\ndiff from scratch: 60-file pull request pushed five times cost five full reviews, and\n`INLINE_COMMENT_CROSS_RUN_DEDUP_ENABLED` only stopped same COMMENT being posted twice — it\nnever saved single token. With size caps removed and reviews sharded, that repeat cost is\nmultiplied by shard count, so…

Bash input={"command":"wc -l application/services/review_incremental.py application/models/finding.py application/config.py application/integrations/prompts/review_instruction.txt application/services/review_aggregate.py application/services/review_service.py application/integrations/codex_client.py application/integrations/claude_code_client.py application/integrations/review_prompt.py scripts/export_eval_data.py application/models/config.py application/models/bitbucket_credential.py application/services/config_service.py application/repositories/finding_repository.py application/models/review_event.py application/schemas.… output={"stdout":" 146 application/services/review_incremental.py\n 159 application/models/finding.py\n 1417 application/config.py\n 36 application/integrations/prompts/review_instruction.txt\n 242 application/services/review_aggregate.py\n 1432 application/services/review_service.py\n 321 application/integrations/codex_client.py\n 508 application/integrations/claude_code_client.py\n 410 application/integrations/review_prompt.py\n 268 scripts/export_eval_data.py\n 53 application/models/config.py\n 181 application/models/bitbucket_credential.py\n 289 application/services/…

Bash input={"command":"git status --short; cat documentation/architecture/review-output.md documentation/architecture/incremental-review.md documentation/architecture/sharded-review.md"} output={"stdout":"# Review output: prompt, finding fields, and what reaches PR\n\n_Moved out of CLAUDE.md on 2026-09-06 so it loads only when relevant. Source of truth for behaviour is code and its tests; this is rationale and invariants._\n\n## Review output: prompt, finding fields, and what reaches PR\n\nThe review instruction (`app/integrations/prompts/review_instruction.txt`) is senior-reviewer\nbrief, not output contract: 7-point rubric in priority order, explicit d…

Bash input={"command":"mkdir -p /tmp/improver-run && python3./.claude/skills/knowledge-graph/scripts/build_knowledge_graph.py --root. > /tmp/improver-run/kg.log 2>&1; echo exit=$?; tail -20 /tmp/improver-run/kg.log; cat documentation/architecture/review-output.md documentation/architecture/incremental-review.md documentation/architecture/sharded-review.md"} output={"stdout":"exit=0\nSCAN: COMPARE\nDRIFT REPORTED base <59f642386d891001a19f5f192d30762ea13de74b> -> head <e0cf23c39b6a7787e87d4a4c1dec1cab1323a93c>\n\nEntry points +2: [('.claude/skills/knowledge-graph/scripts/build_knowledge_graph.py', 'main'), ('scripts/export_eval_data.py', 'main')] -0: []\nFunctions +90: [('.claude/skills/knowledge-graph/scripts/build_knowledge_graph.py', '__init__'), ('.claude/skills/knowledge-graph/scripts/build_knowledge_graph.py', '_assign_targets_and_value'), …

Bash input={"command":"ls application application/services application/integrations application/integrations/prompts application/models application/repositories application/utils scripts alembic/versions | head -200; wc -l documentation/architecture/review-output.md documentation/architecture/incremental-review.md documentation/architecture/sharded-review.md"} output={"stdout":"ls: cannot access 'alembic/versions': No such file or directory\napp:\n__init__.py\n__pycache__\nconfig.py\nconsumer\ndb.py\ndeps.py\nintegrations\nlogging_config.py\nmain.py\nmodels\nredis_client.py\nrepositories\nrouters\nschemas.py\nschemas_api.py\nsecurity\nseed.py\nservices\nsso\nstatic\nstatic_spa\ntracing.py\nutils\n\napp/integrations:\n__init__.py\n__pycache__\naws.py\nbitbucket_client.py\nbitbucket_comment.py\nclaude_auth.py\nclaude_code_client.py\ncodex_client.py\ngit_ops.py…

Bash input={"command":"ls -d./.claude/kredivo-docs ~/.claude/kredivo-docs 2>/dev/null | head -1; for p in ~/.claude/skills/knowledge-graph/scripts/build_knowledge_graph.py./.claude/skills/knowledge-graph/scripts/build_knowledge_graph.py skills/knowledge-graph/scripts/build_knowledge_graph.py; do [ -f $p ] && echo FOUND $p; done; ls; ls knowledge-graph*.index.yaml 2>/dev/null; git log --oneline -1"} output={"stdout":"FOUND /root/.claude/skills/knowledge-graph/scripts/build_knowledge_graph.py\nFOUND./.claude/skills/knowledge-graph/scripts/build_knowledge_graph.py\nCLAUDE.md\nDockerfile-consumer\nDockerfile-consumer-local\nDockerfile-web\nDockerfile-web-local\nREADME.md\nalembic.ini\napp\nbitbucket-pipelines.yml\nbuild_push_image.sh\ndata\ndocker-compose.yml\ndocs\nfrontend\njira-ticket.md\nknowledge-graph.index.yaml\nknowledge-graph.yaml\nlocalstack\nmigration_script.sql\nmigrations\npyproject.tom…

AskUserQuestion input={"answers":{"Build/use  knowledge-graph map of this codebase to help scope this improvement's blast radius? It's static call-graph scan (file/function/call relationships, ranked hubs) — more reliable than grep alone for finding real callers.":"Use it (Recommended)","When tests pass, commit these changes locally, or leave them uncommitted so you can review first?":"Commit locally","Which branch should this work go on?":"Current branch (documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback)"},"questions":[{"header":"Bra… output={"questions":[{"header":"Branch","multiSelect":false,"options":[{"description":"Branch off current documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback HEAD so eval doc is included.","label":"New branch improve/eval-noise-bluf (Recommended)"},{"description":"Add implementation on top of eval-doc branch.","label":"Current branch (documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback)"}],"question":"Which branch should this work go on?"},{"header":"Know. graph","multiSelect":false,"options":[{"description":"Run knowledge-graph …

Bash input={"command":"git status --short --branch; git branch --show-current; grep -c 'beehive:improver-skill-auto-invoke' CLAUDE.md 2>/dev/null"} output={"stdout":"## documentation/pr-agent-eval-feedback...origin/docs/pr-agent-eval-feedback\ndocs/pr-agent-eval-feedback\n1","stderr":"","interrupted":false,"isImage":false,"noOutputExpected":false}

Skill input={"skill":"improver","arguments":"Implement Tahap (usulan 1, 2, 3, 4, 7) and Tahap B (usulan 5, 6, 8, BLUF format, export chat_messages) from documentation/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md. BLUF format must be optional per-repo setting, default disabled, so it can be trialed on selected repositories first."} output={"success":true,"commandName":"improver"}

Bash input={"command":"cat /home/etc/claude-code/work/osprey/docs/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md"} output={"stdout":"# PR agent eval feedback — 2026-09-17\n\nAnalisis data eval review bot (7 hari terakhir) terhadap tiga keluhan user, plus feedback lain yang\nditemukan dari data dan codebase. Dokumen ini adalah temuan + usulan; **belum ada perubahan kode**.\n\n- **Data:** `data/eval_data/eval_export_7d_20260917T112201Z.jsonl` (gitignored), hasil\n `python -m scripts.export_eval_data --days 7 --include-diff`\n- **Cakupan:** 259 review, 177 PR unik, 1.274 finding, 720 inline comment terposting\n- **En…

Based on documentation/eval/2026-09-17-pr-agent-eval-feedback.md, implement improvement yang dan B dulu, yang BLUFF ini dijadikan optional per repository dengan default disable. Saya ingin uji coba selected repository dulu